Rene girards mimetic desire as seen in the writings of. Simone weil s the iliad, or the poem of force is one of her most celebrated works an inspired analysis of homers epic that presents a nightmare vision of combat as a machine in which all humanity is lost. Weil, a philosopher, social activist, marxist, and ascetic, admired the iliad for its honesty in treating the realities of war, its foregrounding of love in different relationships. The relation between hannah arendt and simone weil can be viewed through the sign of a double paradox. War and the iliad joins together for the first time in a single volume simone weil s ferocious lament the iliad or the poem of force, with her less well known contemporary rachel bespaloffs antiphonal meditation on conflict, pacifism and justice. Her profound meditation on the nature of violence provides a remarkably vivid and accessible testament. Jun 29, 2015 simone weil, the iliad or the poem of force, december 1940 born in paris, in february 1909 into an agnostic french jewish family, simone weil died of cardiac failure in august 1943. At an age when most children can barely see beyond their own shifting desires, simone weil had fully grasped the reality and the meaning of sacrifice. Southern illinois university press, 1966, 62 more spiritual after 1938 but still concerned with af. Simone weil project gutenberg selfpublishing ebooks.
When david cameron, the uk prime minister, stood up in parliament to argue in favour of air strikes on syria he was stepping into a role that stretches all the way back to achilles, the hero of homers epic poem the iliad. Weil hammers home the point that those who possess force do so only apparently and always temporarily. Simone weil s the iliad, or the poem of force is one of her most celebrated worksan inspired analysis of homers epic that presents a nightmare vision of combat as a machine in which all humanity is lost. In her writings she investigated religion, science and art with a true love for god and humanity. Nov 18, 2017 for simone weil, the iliad was not about the gods, the strategies, the treaties, the entreaties, and the negotiations of warring parties. Simona giurgea performing simone weils essay the iliad. Simone weil wrote her powerful essay, the iliad, or the poem of force, in 193940, during the fall of france, her native country, to the nazis. Simone weil was a french philosopher, writer, labor activist, theologian, revolutionary, and mystic. Davis this marvelous essay by french philosopher, activist, and christian mystic simone weil came along at just the right time for me. It first discusses weil s personal background, then focuses on her reaction tointerpretation of the. An essay on violence but words of reason drop into the void. The nyrb classics series is designedly and determinedly exploratory and eclectic, a. The force that men wield, the force that subdues men, in the face of which human flesh shrinks back.
A science which does not bring us nearer to god is worthless. Simone weils the iliad, or the poem of force is one of her most celebrated worksan inspired analysis of homers epic that presents a nightmare vision of combat as a machine in which all humanity is lost. War and the iliad war and the iliad is a perfect introduction to the range of homers art as well as a provocative and rewarding demonstration of the links between literature, philosophy, and questions of. Simone weil was concerned with force and the iliad as a story of war. War and the iliad by hermann broch, simone weil and rachel. Simone weil 19091943 wrote her slim but powerful book. Simone weil, rachel bespaloff, hermann broch, christopher benfey.
Apr, 2016 download simone weils the iliad or the poem of force a critical edition read online. Seventyfive years ago, as the nazis were methodically implementing their conquest of europe, the french philosophermystic simone weil published a long essay titled the iliad, or the poem of force. The iliad, or the poem of force, in 1940, after the fall of her native france to the nazis. Download simone weils the iliad or the poem of force a. Weil s essay attempts to explain the mentality of the characters in the poem when they are in victory or in despair, what its real subject is the subject is force, power, might, which is defined as that which makes a thing of anybody who comes under its sway. The hero is force, she says, the ways in which men oppress other men. War and the iliad by simone weil, rachel bespaloff. Simone weil s the iliad, or the poem of force is one of her most celebrated worksan inspired analysis of homers epic that presents a nightmare vision of combat as a machine in which all. Published by the lapis press posted on december 31, 2015 by j. Simone weil 19091943 was one of the first female graduates of the ecole normale superieure and taught philosophy in provincial schools from 1931 to 1938. Intellectually precocious, weil also expressed social awareness at an early age. Simone weil s essay shows you a woman reading the iliad in an extraordinarily sensitive way. Simone weil 19091943 philosophized on thresholds and across borders.
Dec 07, 2015 simone weil was a french philosopher, writer, labor activist, theologian, revolutionary, and mystic. Simone weil, the iliad or the poem of force, december 1940 born in paris, in february 1909 into an agnostic french jewish family, simone weil died of. The true hero, the true subject, the center of the iliad is force. Mary mccarthy was the original translator, and her luminous work is reprinted here. Weil was born in her parents apartment in paris on 3 february 1909, the daughter of bernard, a medical doctor, and saolomea weil. So begins simone weil s the iliad or, the poem of force, an incredible essay that will change the way you look at war forever. Rene girards mimetic desire as seen in the writings of simone weil e. Weil poignantly characterizes the plight of the slaves, generally women and children, taken in war.
Panichas, introduction to the simone weil reader london. Even as a child, simone weil had an understanding of both the deprivations and the depredations of war. First published on the eve of war in 1939, the essay has often been read as a. Weil, simone, bespaloff, rachel, mccarthy, mary, benfey, christopher. Weil, a philosopher, social activist, marxist, and ascetic, admired the iliad for its honesty in treating the realities of war, its foregrounding of love in different relationships, and the equity. War and the iliad by simone weil, rachel bespaloff, mary. Her profound meditation on the nature of violence provides a remarkably vivid and accessible testament of the greek epics continuing relevance to our lives.
Warriors in the iliad may enjoy shortlived triumphs, but they will eventually taste defeat. The most compelling thing she sees in homers poem of war is the idea of force. Force employed by man, force that enslaves man, force before which mans flesh shrinks away. For weil, the iliad reveals dehumanizing effects of force on victors and. Achilles death follows hectors as surely as hectors does that of patroclus. After her graduation from formal education, weil became a teacher.
Iliad or the poem of force by simone weil librarything. Simone weil, french mystic, social philosopher, and activist in the french resistance during world war ii, whose posthumously published works had particular influence on french and english social thought. Weil was a healthy baby for her first six months, but then suffered a severe attack of appendicitis. Examples in the iliad are chryseis, briseis, and, as foreseen by hector, andromache. The iliad was, in its essence, a poetic study of the subjection of men to the determinations of force, and an account of the consequence of its exercise both on those who would wield it and those who are. A socialist, she worked for a time on the renault assembly line and volunteered to fight against the fascists in the spanish civil war. She calls the iliad the purest and loveliest of mirrors for the way it. It may thus be read as an indirect commentary on that tragic event, which signalized the triumph of the most extreme modern ex pression of force. The true hero, the true subject matter, the center of the iliad is force.
The essay is about homers epic poem the iliad and contains reflections on the conclusions one can draw from the epic regarding the nature of force in human affairs. War and the iliad simone weil paperback books online. Simona giurgea performing simone weils essay the iliad or. Ive written before about weil see my two blog posts, part 1 and part 2, which survey her fascinating life. The iliad is about power but the truth is no one in the poem really just prior to world war ii and in the early years of the war, as the world tipped into chaos, two remarkable writers, simone weil and. First published on the eve of war in 1939, the essay has often been read as a pacifist manifesto. Her persistent desire for truth and justice led her to both elite academies and factory floors, political praxis and spiritual solitude. Weil, simone, the iliad, or the poem of force, chicago. Simone weil, a brilliant young teacher, philosopher, and social activist, wrote the essay, the iliad or the poem of force at france at the beginning of world war ii. Download simone weils the iliad or the poem of force a critical edition read online. Or, the poem of force was written early in world war ii and first published under the pseudonym emile novis in december, 1940, and january, 1941, in cahiers du sud, a journal. The iliad or the poem of force simone weil originally published in politics, november 1945.
Simone weil s the iliad, or the poem of force is one of her most celebrated worksan inspired analysis of homers epic that presents a. Simone weil the iliad, or the poem of force the iliad, or, the poem of force was written in the summer and fall of 1940, after the fall of france. May 26, 2006 simone weil, a brilliant young teacher, philosopher, and social activist, wrote the essay, the iliad or the poem of force at france at the beginning of world war ii. It first discusses weils personal background, then focuses on her reaction tointerpretation of the. The philosophy of simone weil university of edinburgh. War and the iliad is a perfect introduction to the range of homers art as well as a provocative and rewarding demonstration of the links between literature, philosophy, and questions of life and death simone weil s the iliad, or the poem of force is one of her most celebrated worksan inspired analysis of homers epic that presents a nightmare vision of combat as a machine. First of all, theirs is the sign of a missed encounter. In her perceptive take on homers poem, she describes force as the true hero, the true subject, the center of the iliad, and defines it as that x that turns anybody who. The iliad is about power but the truth is no one in the poem really just prior to world war ii and in the early years of the war, as the world tipped into chaos, two remarkable writers, simone weil and rachel bespaloff, wrote independently and brilliantly about the iliad. War and the iliad by simone weil, rachel bespaloff and a great selection of related books, art and collectibles available now at. Not to be confused with simone veil, a french politician. This chapter falls into three closely interrelated parts.
705 544 1233 1148 1065 699 1162 1181 1161 66 400 924 301 120 1163 738 1233 991 108 939 1437 1375 768 268 654 425 1249 379 976 1346 663 249 61 901 1377